My Love for You Was Always Silent Chapter 02

My eyes burned, and the ring on the floor blurred in front of me.

I picked it up and tossed it in the trash.

I hadn’t noticed when the call ended. A moment later, a text popped up with my flight confirmation. The plane left the next morning.

In the group chat for the five of us, Wes tagged me.

Wes: [Claire, where are you? We saved you some venison. Don’t go getting jealous of Sienna again.]

Jenna and Sienna both sent the same GIF of a bunny tapping its foot.

Ethan sent me a private message instead.

Ethan: [We wanted to give you a real birthday. Come on over.]

My heart softened a little. Maybe I could still say a proper goodbye to them.

But by the time I changed and took a cab over, they were all slumped in their chairs, full and happy.

Sienna gave me a soft smile. “Claire, you made it. Come have something to eat.”

I walked over. All that was left on the table were two plates of greens and a few meatballs.

The restaurant’s famous venison was gone, leaving only a few plates of bloody juice from the thawed meat and a faint gamey smell.

I clapped a hand over my mouth and gagged.

Jenna pouted. “Claire, come on. You’re not the one who’s pregnant, so what are you gagging for?”

Wes jumped in. “On soap operas, that’s called faking a pregnancy to steal the spotlight.”

I finally got my churning stomach under control and asked in a hoarse voice, “Why didn’t you wait for me?”

We had promised each other that as long as the five of us were together, we would never leave anyone behind.

Ethan pulled me down into a seat. “Sienna’s pregnant. She can’t go hungry, so we ate with her first. Order whatever you want now.”

I didn’t move, so Ethan ordered a few things for me.

Then a server walked in. “I’m sorry, Ms. Monroe, but the prepaid Diamond card under your name is out of funds. You’ll need to add more before we can put in the order.”

Wes muttered, “Already? We’ve only been here three times this month.”

Jenna yanked hard on his sleeve and shot him a warning look.

The Antler Lodge card was in my name, but it was really a shared account for all five of us. I made a little more money than the others, so I was always the one who topped it up.

Ethan kept the card, though.

Sienna and Jenna had complained that I was a workaholic. If I held on to the card, they couldn’t order until I showed up, but if Ethan had it, they could order ahead.

Every one of them had promised to wait for me.

Instead, they ate without me again and again. More than once, I showed up to nothing but scraps.

In the end, I was the one eating leftovers and using my overtime pay to refill the card.

I stood up, my appetite gone. “Don’t refill it. Close the account for me.”

Ethan grabbed my wrist. “Claire, it’s only a few meals. You’re being ridiculous.”

The air in the private room went tense.

I looked over at Wes and Jenna. I hadn’t known a thing about the three dinners they had eaten there that month.

I had suggested dinner in the group chat three times, too. Every time, the answer was that everyone was busy and we would do it another time.

The last message in that chat was still the “Home now” I had sent the week before.

It suddenly hit me that they might have a group chat I wasn’t in.

I looked Ethan right in the eye. “Is it really only a few meals? Two months ago, you all went to the hot springs at Frostridge and didn’t invite me.”

“Six months ago, you went camping outside the city without me. Last year, you went hiking without me.”

Wes clicked his tongue. “Don’t be so petty. We figured it was hard for you to get time off, so we didn’t ask.”

So I didn’t even deserve to know. Yet Sienna, who had married and moved out of state, could always find a way to join their trips.

Sienna bit her lip and gave me an apologetic look. “I thought they’d told you. I honestly had no idea.”

None of them knew that someone had forwarded me Sienna’s Instagram post. It was a group photo of the four of them at the hot springs, and they all looked so happy.

Sienna: [You wouldn’t understand how much more fun it is with one less person.]

Ryan Cole, the friend who forwarded the post, had sent a question with it.

Ryan: [Claire, did you stop hanging out with them?]

Ryan didn’t know that we all still lived under the same roof. I couldn’t even squeeze into a corner of their group photos anymore. I had been pushed out completely.

I tugged free and noticed that Ethan’s wrist was bare. My heart sank.

“Where’s the watch I gave you?”

Ethan’s index finger twitched a few times at his side. He always did that when he had something to hide.

Sienna reached in between Ethan and me to pull us apart. “Claire, calm down!”

My eyes locked onto her and stayed there.

Sienna jerked her hand back on reflex and covered her wrist, but she couldn’t hide the silver band.

I grabbed the hand she was pulling away and knocked Jenna’s and Wes’ hands aside when they tried to stop me. Then I turned on Ethan.

“Why would you give her that watch? Don’t you know what that watch…”

Ethan smacked my forearm hard enough to leave a red mark and yanked Sienna’s hand out of my grip.

Ethan had put Sienna behind him. Her face was already wet with tears, and Wes held her close as she sobbed and tried to pull the watch off.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
*** GPTtag - Anchor ***