He Loved Me When I Stopped Wanting Him Chapter 04

I set the ice pack on the chair beside him.

 

“A staff member asked me to bring this over,” I said evenly. “You can put it on yourself.”

 

I turned to leave, but he spoke.

 

“Still mad?”

 

I stopped and looked at him, puzzled.

 

“About the earrings.”

 

“If it bothers you, I can get you something else.”

 

“How about those headphones you liked?”

 

Even as he spoke, there was a patronizing confidence in his expression.

 

As if all he had to do was be a little nicer to me, and I should come running back.

 

I was about to tell him not to bother when a teammate nudged his arm.

 

Lily was approaching, her eyes red.

 

“What happened? How did you get hurt?”

 

Noah smiled at her.

 

“It’s nothing. Just a little sprain.”

 

Lily picked up the ice pack.

 

“Let me hold it for you.”

 

Noah covered her hand with his, his voice gentle.

 

“I’ve got it. Don’t keep holding that. It’s too cold.”

 

For a moment, I felt dazed.

 

Over the past two years, I’d held ice packs for Noah so many times that my fingertips had turned red from the cold. He’d never once said anything like that to me.

 

The players stood nearby, looking awkwardly from Lily to me.

 

I understood. Time to go.

 

By the time Noah looked up again, I was gone.

 

Mia said something had come up at home and she needed to drive back early. She asked if I wanted to come.

 

I said I wanted to watch the rest of the game. I could take the bus afterward.

 

I sat alone in the stands until it was over.

 

The other school won.

 

Watching Ethan shake hands with our players on the court, I sighed.

 

Did that guy even know what second place felt like?

 

Only as everyone was leaving did I realize it was pouring outside.

 

It had been sunny when I left home. I hadn’t brought an umbrella.

 

I didn’t have a car, and the rideshare app kept failing to find me a driver.

 

The nearest bus stop was about a quarter mile away.

 

I was debating whether to make a run for it when I heard Noah behind me.

 

“No umbrella?”

 

Then Lily spoke.

 

“Come with us. Noah’s umbrella is huge. We can probably fit three people under it.”

 

Noah opened the large black umbrella in his hand.

 

I remembered staying at the school library until closing once and coming out to find it raining.

 

He’d walked me back to my apartment under that same umbrella.

 

It really was big. Two people could stand beneath it without getting wet at all.

 

But there probably wasn’t room for a third.

 

I had enough sense to see that.

 

I shook my head.

 

“No, thanks. You two go ahead.”

 

Noah looked at me.

 

“I’ll take Lily to the bus stop first, then come back for you.”

 

“I won’t be long.”

 

I didn’t answer. He took that as agreement.

 

Then he and Lily walked out into the rain, side by side.

 

Half an hour passed. Instead of stopping, the rain came down harder.

 

Water had begun pooling in the low spots of the parking lot.

 

Half an hour was enough time to walk to the bus stop and back several times.

 

I pushed the pointless thought aside and scrolled through my phone.

 

When Mia found out I was stuck at the sports center, she wanted to drive over and pick me up.

 

I told her not to bother. Maybe the rain would stop if I waited a little longer.

 

A few seconds later, she sent me a screenshot from social media.

 

[Just saw this. Nice to know they’ve got time for a date in the middle of a downpour.]

 

It was Lily’s account.

 

The post showed a dessert shop, along with a photo of her and Noah together.

 

The caption read: [Finally trying this new place! Not even the rain can keep me from dessert!]

 

I checked the location.

 

Right across from the bus stop.

 

Remembering Noah’s “I won’t be long,” I couldn’t help smiling a little.

 

Good thing I hadn’t expected much in the first place.

 

With no sign of the rain letting up, I decided to run straight to the bus stop.

 

I’d barely taken a step when a hand settled on my shoulder.

 

“What’s the rush? Your umbrella’s here.”

 

Startled, I turned and found myself looking into Ethan’s eyes.

 

He let out a lazy yawn.

 

Before the game, he’d told his coach he’d make his own way home. He’d planned to get a ride with a teammate.

 

But after the game, he’d fallen asleep in the lounge. His teammate had assumed he’d made other arrangements and left without waking him.

 

His umbrella was a translucent sky blue. When he opened it, even the dull gray sky seemed a little brighter.

 

He put an arm around my shoulders and steered me outside.

 

“Hey,” I said immediately. “Who said you could put your arm around me?”

 

He gave me a helpless look.

 

“The umbrella’s too small. If we don’t stay close, we’ll both get soaked.”

 

“Where are you headed?”

 

“The bus stop.”

 

We were halfway there when hurried footsteps sounded ahead.

 

A second later, a hand reached beneath the umbrella, grabbed me, and yanked me out.

 

Noah was glaring at Ethan, his expression frighteningly dark.

 

“What are you doing?”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
*** GPTtag - Anchor ***