He Loved Me When I Stopped Wanting Him Chapter 03

Noah stared at me, probably not expecting me to apologize so readily.

 

I was about to return to my seat when Lily suddenly stepped forward again and looked at my ears.

 

“Oh, you’re not wearing the earrings?”

 

“Noah picked those out especially at the jewelry store.”

 

“He asked me if I wanted them first, but my ears aren’t pierced. So I told him you’d love them.”

 

Noah’s expression shifted.

 

“Lily, you didn’t need to say that.”

 

She covered her mouth as if she’d only just realized she’d said something wrong.

 

“Oh my God, I’m sorry. I wasn’t thinking again. That’s not what I meant. I just thought those earrings would look really good on you.”

 

A few classmates laughed at how flustered she looked.

 

“I didn’t even follow all of that, but I couldn’t possibly be mad at her when she looks like that.”

 

“Exactly. Emma, she didn’t mean anything by it.”

 

Mia hadn’t pieced together the whole story, but she understood the look on my face.

 

She’d also just learned that Noah had stood me up yesterday. Frowning, she immediately came over to defend me.

 

I caught her arm.

 

As it happened, I’d brought the earrings with me.

 

I’d thought about it for a long time the night before. If I’d decided to give up on Noah, I shouldn’t keep accepting his gifts.

 

I took the jewelry box out of my backpack and held it out to him.

 

His expression darkened.

 

“What’s this supposed to mean?”

 

“I’m not getting my ears pierced. I can’t use them, so I’m giving them back.”

 

“They were a gift.”

 

I glanced at Lily.

 

“You gave them to me because Lily didn’t want them.”

 

He frowned.

 

“Why do you have to make an issue of that? You never used to—”

 

“That was before.”

 

Before, I would have treasured anything he gave me, even a rock he’d picked up off the ground.

 

So he probably thought I was easy to satisfy.

 

But that was because I liked him. I wanted to make him happy.

 

I didn’t need to do that anymore.

 

He wouldn’t take the box.

 

I set it on the empty low bookshelf by the door and returned to my seat, not bothering to look at his increasingly angry expression.

 

Finally, I could study in peace.

 

After that, Noah started giving me the silent treatment.

 

Even when we passed each other in the hallway, he’d walk right by as if he hadn’t seen me.

 

Mia was furious.

 

“Who does he think he is? Is he seriously waiting for you to go make him feel better?”

 

Mia was the only person who knew I’d given up on Noah.

 

When I first told her, she nearly leaped out of her chair.

 

“About time! Emma, you deserve someone so much better!”

 

That Saturday, our basketball team was playing a friendly against another nearby high school.

 

The game was at the city sports center.

 

Mia said there was a guy on the other team who was even hotter than Noah, and she insisted on dragging me along.

 

When we got there, I discovered she was talking about Ethan.

 

At a previous state math competition, he’d placed first and I’d placed second.

 

Whenever he competed, I usually had to settle for second.

 

He’d always been the opponent I wanted most to beat.

 

Noah was playing, too.

 

Before the game started, he glanced up at the stands and quickly spotted me.

 

Even from that distance, I could see the corners of his mouth turn up.

 

I used to come to every one of his games, bringing him water and handing him towels.

 

He probably thought this time would be no different.

 

Halfway through the game, I got thirsty and went to the concession area to buy a bottle of water.

 

When I came back, play had stopped.

 

A group of people had gathered around Noah.

 

A staff member noticed me looking over and handed me a disposable ice pack.

 

“Could you take this over to the bench? Number seven. Thanks. I need to deal with something at the entrance.”

 

He hurried away before I could answer.

 

I had no choice but to take the ice pack over.

 

The players started teasing as soon as they saw me.

 

“See? I knew Emma wouldn’t be able to stay away when she heard you were hurt.”

 

“She even brought you an ice pack. You going to hold it on for him, too?”

 

Noah had fallen and sprained his wrist trying to catch himself. It was already swelling.

 

The others stepped aside as I approached.

 

He looked straight at me, his eyes brighter than usual.

 

“You came.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
*** GPTtag - Anchor ***