He Loved Me When I Stopped Wanting Him Chapter 02

My heart still skipped a beat when I saw the message.

 

But I reminded myself, over and over, that Noah didn’t like me.

 

I took my phone and went downstairs.

 

He was standing beside the entrance to my building, holding a cake box.

 

When I walked over, he handed it to me.

 

“Lily picked it out. When she heard it was your birthday, she insisted I bring it over.”

 

My hand paused halfway up, but I took it in the end.

 

Mango cake.

 

I’d told Noah many times that I was allergic to mangoes.

 

“What? You don’t like it?”

 

I shook my head and looked at him.

 

“Tell her I said thank you.”

 

“If that’s everything, I’m going back upstairs.”

 

I’d just turned when he stopped me again.

 

“Wait. There’s this, too.”

 

He took a small box out of his coat pocket.

 

Inside was a pair of stud earrings.

 

“Your birthday present.”

 

The question slipped out before I could stop it.

 

“Did Lily pick these out, too?”

 

He hesitated.

 

“I bought them myself.”

 

I tucked my hair behind my ear.

 

“But my ears aren’t pierced.”

 

The corners of his mouth lifted slightly.

 

He didn’t say anything, but I could guess what he meant.

 

Since they were from him, of course I’d get my ears pierced so I could wear them.

 

And before, I really would have.

 

But now I knew Noah didn’t like me.

 

If we weren’t going to be together, there was no reason for me to do that anymore.

 

Still, I didn’t embarrass him to his face.

 

I accepted the box and thanked him.

 

He looked at me with his usual detached expression.

 

“Something unexpected came up this time. I’ll spend your next birthday with you.”

 

Hearing that no longer gave me the thrill it once would have.

 

I yawned.

 

“We can worry about that when the time comes. I still have problems to finish.”

 

Noah seemed surprised by my reaction.

 

He was about to say something else when his phone rang.

 

He answered immediately, his voice softening as he spoke.

 

“Lily? Yeah, I dropped off the cake. She said she loved it…”

 

I smiled a little, turned, and went inside.

 

The next morning, before our first-period English literature class, Mia sat down beside me.

 

Our seats in that class hadn’t changed all semester.

 

She’d barely set down her backpack before she leaned over.

 

“So, where did you and Noah go yesterday?”

 

“Nowhere.”

 

“What? Didn’t you say he promised a month ago to spend your birthday with you?”

 

“Something came up.”

 

I opened the novel we were reading for class and began organizing my annotations.

 

She narrowed her eyes at me.

 

“Something’s off. How are you not disappointed?”

 

Just then, someone knocked twice on the open classroom door.

 

I looked up to see Lily smiling at me, with Noah standing behind her.

 

Conversation immediately picked up around the nearby desks.

 

“Look at that. The two most photogenic people in school.”

 

“They really do look good together.”

 

“Keep it down. Don’t you know Emma likes Noah?”

 

“She’s been chasing him for two years. They’re still not together, are they?”

 

A few people shot me teasing looks.

 

If I’d had the nerve to pursue Noah for two years, I’d certainly never considered liking him anything to be ashamed of.

 

I ignored the comments and walked to the door.

 

“Did you need something?”

 

Lily gave me a sweet smile.

 

“Emma, did you eat the cake? Was it good? I spent forever picking it out.”

 

More whispered comments came from nearby.

 

“Lily’s so nice. Getting a cake for a girl who likes the same guy she does.”

 

“She’s not even chasing Noah. Isn’t he the one following her around?”

 

Noah heard them, but he didn’t deny it.

 

Whenever someone used to joke that he liked me, he’d immediately tell them to stop making things up.

 

“I’m allergic to mangoes, so I couldn’t eat it,” I said. “I gave it to a neighbor. But I appreciate the thought. Thank you.”

 

Lily’s smile froze.

 

Then her eyes widened, and she clasped her hands anxiously.

 

“Oh my God, I’m so sorry. I really didn’t know. I should’ve asked first. That was so careless of me…”

 

I was about to tell her it was all right.

 

Suddenly, Noah stepped in front of her and frowned at me.

 

“Did you have to say that in front of everyone? Lily just transferred here. She didn’t know about your allergy. You don’t need to embarrass her like this.”

 

The doorway fell silent. Everyone was looking at us.

 

I still had reading annotations to finish. I didn’t want to waste my time here.

 

Besides, I knew exactly when to back down.

 

So I looked at Lily.

 

“Sorry. I wasn’t trying to embarrass you. Don’t worry about it.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
*** GPTtag - Anchor ***