My Family Faked Their Deaths. I Really Died. Chapter 12

Chloe’s trial began in April.

The prosecutor charged her with reckless endangerment, filing false reports, and fraud. Mason’s recording from her apartment changed everything. It proved the “prank” wasn’t about teaching me a lesson.

It was about taking my husband.

Mom sat behind the defense table every day. Dad sat behind the prosecution.

On the third day, the prosecutor called Mom to the stand.

Chloe’s lawyer had begged her to testify that Chloe was “a sweet girl who made a mistake.” Mom had promised she would.

She sat down. She took the oath. She looked at Chloe.

Then she reached into her purse and pulled out a pink notebook with a broken lock.

“This was Ivy’s diary,” she said. “From when she was eleven. I found it when we packed up the house.”

The courtroom went quiet.

Mom opened it to a page she’d marked with a sticky note. Her voice shook.

“Today was my birthday. Nobody remembered until dinner. Chloe had a recital so we went to that instead. Mom said I’m old enough to understand. I said okay. I always say okay.

When I grow up I’m going to have one birthday where everybody is there. Just one. Where nobody leaves early, I’ll never ask for anything else ever again.”

Mom closed the diary.

“She was asking for that birthday for seventeen years,” Mom said. “And when she finally asked, we used it to destroy her.”

She turned to the jury.

“I’m the one who taught Chloe that her sister didn’t count. I praised Chloe for everything. I told Ivy to be grown up about everything. I recorded the message that broke my daughter’s heart. And I’m going to plead guilty to my own charges tomorrow.”

Chloe shot up. “Mom! You’re supposed to be on MY side!”

Mom looked at her youngest child for a long time.

“I was always on your side,” she said quietly. “That’s the problem. I was never once on hers.”

She stepped down from the stand.

I stood in the aisle as she passed. For one second, I swear, she slowed down. Like she felt me there.

“I choose you, Ivy,” she whispered to the empty air. “I’m so sorry it took this.”

I had waited twenty-eight years to hear those words.

I didn’t know whether to scream or cry. So I did neither. I just let them sink in.

Then Mason took the stand.

He told them everything. The fake blood. The redirected phones. His own words: Do something. He didn’t

hide a single piece of it.

At the end, the prosecutor asked, “Mr. Reed, do you believe Chloe Harlow intended for her sister to die?”

Mason was silent for a long time.

“I believe she wanted Ivy to disappear,” he said. “She just never thought about what that word really meant.

None of us did.”

The jury was out for four hours.

Guilty on all counts.

Chloe got six years.

As the deputies cuffed her, she twisted around, searching the courtroom. For Mom. For Dad. For Mason.

Nobody looked back at her.

For the first time in her life, nobody picked Chloe.

I stood beside her as they led her out. I had imagined being angry at this moment. Being satisfied.

But all I felt was tired.

“You don’t have to share anymore,” I told her again, even though she couldn’t hear.

The door closed behind her.

The golden light was waiting at the end of the hallway. It was a little brighter now.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
*** GPTtag - Anchor ***